Info message
Successful operation message
Warning message
Error message

b tapper

146 comments · +1,468 / −1,381 · rank #8581 of 40,276

Fonterra was only able to be established by passing a statute that exempted it from competition law. Hence the government of the day has not only the right bu an obligation to ensure it is not abusing that position,. Judging by the prices we pay in NZ for dairy produce, in some cases more than in Australia for exactly the same branded product, consumers are being rorted by the Fontera monopoly.

+74−18

This writer is obviously convinced that smoking cannabis or condoning this is some sort of moral failing. In that case using alcohol or stimulants such as coffee or mood altering foods like chocolate must be as well. Its this simplistic puritanical approach that led to the misguided war on drugs that has caused so much harm, although nowhere near as much as alcohol has.

+29−4

The Police would have been in no position to charge anyone as the pipes are legal and any evidence was gained by someone illegally entering a property, therefore not admissible. The only thing we can be grateful for is that this individual is no longer with the police, as due process and the rule of law is something he thinks he is exempt from.

+22−1

Completely flawed analysis as the comparison used with other economies is average income, when the rest of the article refers to lower incomes.The whole premise of economic growth from rising productivity relies on increased consumption of goods with ever increasing consumption for resources. Unless someone finds another few earths this is not sustainable.

+21−1

Out of 30 countries in the OECD, NZ has the seventh lowest average effective tax rate. The biggest problem in the NZ tax system is that it has no capital gains tax, there are too many dodges for business, so salary and wage earners pay an unfair share. The tax system needs to change to create a fair system rather than one in which the amount of tax paid is based on the way someone arranges their finances.

+24−8

I hope you dont come near me when Im sailing and I have right of way over power vessels unless they are in a marked channel which they can not safely leave. Given your profound ignorance of the collision regs I hate to think how poor your knowledge of the road code is.

+21−7

For bus hubs afdn transfers to work, either buses have to be extremly punctual or extremely frequent, such as every 5 minutes or less. Neither is the case here so they were never going to work. They are emant to reduce bus congestion inthe central city, but the obvious answer to bus congestion in the central city is to ban other motor vehicles in Willis St, Lambton Quay. Manners St and Courtenay Pl.

+16−2

The preferred prime minister poll is meaningless. The opposition leader is always low until just before an election and the current prime minister high the rest of the time. If the question, who is the current prime minister was asked, the result would be pretty much the same.

+18−6

SUV sales are a sign of the gullible buying something unsuited for what they use it for. Unnecessarily large and unwieldy fro around town. Slow and lumbering on highways. Mind you Audis are for the gullible as well. You can buy a VW, Skoda or Seat with 80% of the same parts for half the price.

+12−1

It would be nice for a change to hear of something the Nats might do rather than endless posturing about what they wont do. They appear to want to change nothing and therefore achieve nothing. The only thing they seem to be good at is producing 40 year olds in conservative suits with the minds and attitudes of 70 year olds.

+23−13

The premise that wealth is earned and therefore deserved is so ludicrous that only those who really want to believe it to justify their greed do so. The main reasons I get paid more than average is because of a degree of intelligence I was born with and more significantly the degree of importance my parents placed on education. A large part of the value of my assets is due to the good luck of timing of buying and selling a house which resulted in a large gain. This timing was due to other reasons that were outside my control rather than for maximising a return. As for inheritances,other than for those who made sacrifices to look after elderly relatives, they are the very definition of an unearned income.

+20−12

The reality is that the construction industry is a disaster, here and overseas. In every other industry the cost of production in real terms has decreased over time, and it is not at the expense of safety or quality. Cars are safer, better quality, last longer with less maintenance and cost less in real terms. Maybe that is becasue they are built in factories not in the rain which the fools in this industry thinks is the way to build quality. Meanwhile productivity in the construction industry has increase 1% in 30 years worldwide, despite a huge increase in expenditure on tools and machines. The whole industry needs a massive shake up. Doing things the same way forever is not good enough. Time it got out of the 19th Century. Blaming regulations is a cop out, NZ has one of the most lightly regulated building regimes in the developed world. its time this backward industry sorted itself out.

+11−3

Dairy and dairy processing is 2.5% of GDP. 1/40 of the economy is hardly the backbone. The more economically sensible decision would be to bottle the water and sell it for $2/l, instead of using 2000l of water to produce 1l of milk that retails for about $2/l.

+9−2

This writer seems to have swallowed the myth of the supposedly large contribution dairy makes to the economy. Dairy farming and processing is 2.5% of GDP, which is obviously a small part of te economy. It has large indirect subsidies for example maintaining a rural road network that is paid for by mostly urban ratepayers but damaged by heavy trucks serving farmers, and the biosecurity costs paid for by taxpayers. Its contribution to exports is 10%, but NZ has a low proportion of exports, ranking in the bottom third of nations by exports as a proportion of GDP. Subtracted from that must be the imports of goods for farm use, and the potential fro dirty dairying to damage the tourism industry. Given that bottled water retails for about the same price as milk, it would make more sense to export water than to turn 2000 litres of water into 1 litre of milk.

+6−0

If it takes 100l of water to make 1 l of milk and bottled water sells for about the same price as milk, dairying is just destroying value, without even thinking about environmental damage and milk processing costs.

+11−6

Look want happened when the building industry was lightly regulated. Billions lost on leaky homes. The construction industry can not be trusted to self certify. The idea that NZ building is heavily regulated compared to elsewhere is a myth. NZ is the third fastest place to get permission to build in the OECD. Collective price fixing by contractors and subcontractors aided by trade suppliers, and the ridiculously high rates from tradesman is a much bigger problem.

+7−3

Jacinda never said she was not pregnant so how did she decieve? if anything her public comments hinted at the possibilty. Few mothers and their partners announce that they are pregnant in the first three months, because of the high risk of miscarriage in the first trimester, and not wanting to publically deal with the heartbreak that comes with that. In New Zealand, unlike the US we dont expect potential prime minsters to have a medical examination or to state if they have any health issues, many of which would affect their job more than the entirely natural and normal process of having a baby. Expecting someone to do otherwise is just plain mean. As for Marks kids being teased, that is just mean and nasty, and unfortunately I suspect these attitudes from other children derive from their parents not the kids themselves.

+10−7

There is a huge difference between leasehold land such as Hunter Valley which is owned by the public and privately owned land. its about time all these leases were updated so the taxpayer get fair value for their ownership. If the leases sell for huge amounts of money, then the lease payments are obviously far too low.

+4−1

Working in another profession, I did not see any serious sexual harassment, but bullying of young staff, unrealistic expectations for working hours, on the vague promise that you would get to be a partner one day were the norm. The professions where the business owners work within the firm, can be best described as organisms that eat their own young. Best thing I ever did was get out of that environment.

+4−3

Linking this to Grenfell Is both unwise and in bad taste. Grenfell had no sprinklers and residents were told not to evacuate neither of which would be the case here. Except for stairwells and buildings where occupants cant quickly evacuate passive fire protection is not a life safety issue. This is being driven by the insurance industry who want others to pay to reduce risk and contractors who make money by installing these products.

+2−1

This writer seems to have swallowed the myth of the supposedly large contribution dairy makes to the economy. Dairy farming and processing is 2.5% of GDP, which is obviously a small part of te economy. It has large indirect subsidies for example maintaining a rural road network that is paid for by mostly urban ratepayers but damaged by heavy trucks serving farmers, and the biosecurity costs paid for by taxpayers. Its contribution to exports is 10%, but NZ has a low proportion of exports, ranking in the bottom third of nations by exports as a proportion of GDP. Subtracted from that must be the imports of goods for farm use, and the potential fro dirty dairying to damage the tourism industry. Given that bottled water retails for about the same price as milk, it would make more sense to export water than to turn 2000 litres of water into 1 litre of milk.

+1−0

Linking cars wont help pedestrians, children, cyclists, horse riders etc. Motor vehicles need to be in dedicated space with restricted access to be truly safe. The idea of an object travelling at up to 100 km/hr with no physical barrier between it and people is actually quite absurd and would not be countenanced in any other setting such as a factory.

+1−0

A more sensible and acceptable move might be to reduce the open road limit to 90 km/hr, but to 110km/hr on roads with a median barrier. Im sure NZTA would say roads arent design to 110, but a road with a median barrier at 110 is far safer than one without at 90 km/hr. More traffic police, focusing also on slow drivers obstructing traffic would more than make up for the loss in time for the reduced speed limit.

+10−9

A balanced article would include the potential costs of these so-called free trade agreements. For example the US trying to push non trade related clauses that are designed to ensure US companies can make more money at our expense. On balance some of these so called free trade agreements may make us worse off when we concede more than we gain so mindlessly pursuing them at any cost is absurd. Also this buys into the myth that NZ is a trading economy whereas considering international trade as a proportion of GDP puts us in the bottom third of countries, with most of those with a lower proportion being much larger economies with less need for trade.

+1−1

Roundabouts only work effectively where there is even traffic flow in all directions, which is relatively rare. Three leg roundabouts dont work. If flows are uneven the dominant traffic flow prevents others from getting on the roundabout leading to frustrated drivers forcing their way onto the roundabout. They are frequently installed primarily to slow traffic which is poor road design..

+3−3

Fire someone with a trivial excuse for having the temerity to try and perform their duties as a health and safety officer, blacklist them so they cant ever work again in the industry losing over a $million in future earnings. Payment ordered by the employment court $40,000. What a joke. Ive run a business in the US. It was impossible to comply with both Federal regs and state law as they were contradictory.

+0−0

This is a rather simplistic analysis that focuses on rates relative to inflation, rather than what ratepayers receive for the money. The cost of services to ratepayers compared tot he cost of provision for services such as water and sewerage compares extremely favorably with things such as electricity line charges,and many councils face enormous cost of renewing infrastructure that is 50-60 years old and nearing the end of its life. Depreciation of this infrastructure was never funded. For many smaller councils person their major expense is roading, yet much of the cost is for building and repairing bridges and roads for heavy vehicles,when the transport industry contributes nothing towards these costs for local roads. Local roads should be paid for by users rather than ratepayers subsidizing private motor vehicle use and goods transport.

+0−0

Nobody made contractors underbid for work. Builders love to blame compliance costs, but why has the consenting processs become so rigorous and risk averse? Because builders built leaking buildings, and unlike builders, Councils cant wind themselves up to avoid liablity and start again under a diffrent name like Ebert/Trebe/Ebert,while their directors keep their multimillion dollar house. The RMA and BA are statute law, that Councils are legally required to enforce. Building is still overpriced in NZ, quality is low, and productivity gains have been close to zero. Whether the industry can force risk back onto clients, or not, will not make this a productive and cost effective industry.

+0−0

So the construction industrys answer is to give them more money, when NZ already has some of the highest construction costs in the World. Spending on equipment and technology has multiplied in the last 30 years but productivity has only increased 1%. Many tasks have not changed since the early 20th century or in some cases the 19th. Time this industry looked at itself rather than blaming everything else.

+1−2

NZ Business needs to realise how good it has it. Lightly regulated, with in most cases only national regulations, and not a plethora of local, state and federal regulations and law. Lax competition law and even laxer enforcement. Employment court giving ineffectual penalties. Third fastest place in the OECD to get permission to build. Seems that the only thing NZ business excels at is whinging.

+4−5